meyerweb.com

Skip to: site navigation/presentation
Skip to: Thoughts From Eric

Luminous Beings

After collecting one hundred posted comments (and four pings) for the post “Wanted: CSS Luminary“, I closed comment posting and tallied the results.  This involved going through the comments and compiling a list of every name that was mentioned.  Once I filtered out duplicate or followup posts, I was left with a list of fifty-six names. Then I counted up the number of posts in which each name appeared, so any post that mentioned the same name more than once only registered a single vote for that person.  That yielded the top ten most-mentioned names, shown in Table 1.

Table 1. Most-mentioned names
RankNameMentions
1 Dave Shea 40
2 Doug Bowman 19
3 Jeffrey Zeldman 17
4 Dan Cederholm 14
5 Andy Budd 12
6 John Gallant 11
Tantek Çelik 11
8 Holly Bergevin 10
9 Molly Holzschlag 8
10 D. Keith Robinson 7

I also decided to do some weighted scoring, like I used to do with the CSS Leader Board back in the day.  For this situation, the first name listed in a post was counted as a ‘primary mention’.  Any name listed second was a ‘secondary mention’, and a name after that a ‘tertiary mention’.  Any names after that were lumped together in a category called ‘hrair mention’, which I guess means I can’t even count as high as rabbits.  I gave five points for every primary mention, three points for every secondary mention, two for a tertiary mention, and one point for each hrair mention.  That yielded the same ten names and the same leaders, but the mid-field order got rearranged, as you can see in Table 2.

Table 2. Highest-scoring names
RankNameScore
1Dave Shea 162
2Doug Bowman 53
3Dan Cederholm 49
John Gallant 49
5Jeffrey Zeldman 47
Tantek Çelik 47
7Holly Bergevin 40
8Molly Holzschlag 38
9Andy Budd 30
10D. Keith Robinson 23

So there you have it: the results of my wholly unscientific and vaguely subjective poll.  I’ll be passing the results along to the publisher in question, mostly by e-mailing the URL of this entry.  My thanks to everyone who responded, and congratulations to those who made the list!  I for one welcome our stylish new overlords.

For reference, here’s the entire list of names that was collected from the comments, sorted alphabetically by last name.

  • Cameron Adams
  • John Allsopp
  • Holly Bergevin
  • Bert Bos
  • Doug Bowman
  • Owen Briggs
  • Andy Budd
  • Dan Cederholm
  • Tantek Çelik
  • Andy Clarke
  • Simon Collison
  • Eric Costello
  • Mike Davidson
  • Kevin Davis
  • Meryl Evans
  • Todd Fahrner
  • John Gallant
  • Peter Gifford
  • Daniel Glazman
  • Danny Goodman
  • Patrick Griffiths
  • Aaron Gustafson
  • Jeremy Hedley
  • Andrei Herasimchuk
  • Jon Hicks
  • Ian Hickson
  • Didier Hilhorst
  • Molly Holzschlag
  • Dave Hyatt
  • Shaun Inman
  • Makiko Itoh
  • Jeremy Keith
  • Egor Kloos
  • Peter-Paul Koch
  • Patrick Lauke
  • Seamus Leahy
  • Håkon Lie
  • ‘Literary Moose’
  • ‘Meg at Mandarin’
  • Cameron Moll
  • Stu Nicholls
  • Paul O’Brien
  • Dunstan Orchard
  • Mike Pick
  • D. Keith Robinson
  • Richard Rutter
  • Blake Scarbrough
  • Christopher Schmitt
  • Dave Shea
  • Sue Sims
  • Petr Stanicek
  • Greg Storey (?)
  • Anne van Kesteren
  • Russ Weakley
  • Simon Willison
  • Jeffrey Zeldman

All right, I lied.  There were three suggested names I left off the list: John Kerry, George W. Bush, and Bill Gates.  I omitted them because none of the three men are known to have spent any time writing about or using CSS.  But hey, if either Kerry or Bush mentions CSS positively in a campaign speech, and isn’t talking about the Content Scrambling System, I’ll give him my vote!

Okay, that’s also a lie.

Three Responses

    • #1
    • Pingback
    • Tue 13 Jul 2004
    • 0401
    Received from Burningbird » If Only

    [...] on a book. I’m so eager that I considered, briefly, putting my name into the list of CSS Luminaries that Eric Meyer asked for recently, for work on a new book on CS [...]

    • #2
    • Trackback
    • Tue 13 Jul 2004
    • 1128
    Received from Yahon blog

    O sont les feeeeemmes?
    C’est un sujet plus ou moins récurrent en webdesign, et que je retrouve aujourd’hui sur plusieurs sites. Récemment Eric Meyer (auteur de Eric Meyer on CSS et de More Eric Meyer on CSS a lancé un appel pour trouver une personne…

    • #3
    • Trackback
    • Mon 19 Jul 2004
    • 0514
    Received from Extension In Use

    Where is the love?
    First there was this, then this, and now we have been subjected to the ‘Whitespace Power Rankings’. Blah. I never really saw the point of popular people exhalting each other in public. I mean, all the design bloggers in these…


July 2004
SMTWTFS
June August
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Sidestep

Feeds

Extras