Skip to: site navigation/presentation
Skip to: Thoughts From Eric

Unjustified Caption Text

I just stumbled across a browser bug this evening that I thought you all might like to know about.  So we all know that IE6/Win supports text-align: justify, right?  Wrong.  Sorry, but it’s the truth: IE6 does not fully support text-align: justify.  True, it mostly supports that declaration, but if you apply said declaration to a caption element, guess what?  You get centered, non-justified text instead.  It’s very much as though, in the case of caption elements, IE6 replaces justify with center.

I just thought I’d pass this along in case it might help anyone else avoid some furious head-scratching.  And, I’m sorry to say, I don’t know of a workaround.  If anyone finds one, please leave a comment to that effect.

This is a perfect illustration of how difficult it is to do comprehensive CSS testing.  Every CSS support chart I’ve ever seen has marked down IE6 as supporting justified text; I mean, why wouldn’t they?  It clearly did so… for the specific test cases used to create that support chart.  The odds of a test page including a caption element are pretty vanishingly small, unless of course we’re talking about a test page that includes every single XHTML element in existence.  And to test every element known for every property-value combination… well, I’ve talked about that before.  No need to trample the same ground even flatter.

12 Responses»

    • #1
    • Comment
    • Thu 9 Dec 2004
    • 0014
    Philippe wrote in to say...

    I’ve done that head-scratching a while ago for a problem with padding Setting it to display:block explicitly did solve my problem. Hmm, according to the html 4.01 specs it is an inline element. Or do I read that wrong ?

    • #2
    • Comment
    • Thu 9 Dec 2004
    • 0022
    Al wrote in to say...


    • #3
    • Comment
    • Thu 9 Dec 2004
    • 0137
    Bernd wrote in to say...

    I think the problem has its root that they use the html align attribute to align text within a caption rather than the caption box. So align=”left” would not put the caption box left to the table as required by html 4.01 but would make the text left aligned.

    • #4
    • Comment
    • Thu 9 Dec 2004
    • 0236
    Roger Johansson wrote in to say...

    The caption element is treated differently in Gecko browsers and Safari too. I don’t remember which is which right now, but if you add a top margin to the table, one of the two will push the caption away (provided the caption is displayed at the top, obviously), and the other will not, which is what I would expect.

    Maybe that has something to do with Philippe’s comment about caption being an inline element. Guess I’ll have to look into that ;)

    • #5
    • Comment
    • Thu 9 Dec 2004
    • 0332
    Anonymous wrote in to say...
    caption is display: table-caption

    The specification is not fully clear if table-caption is treated as block-level, but says:
    “Captions above or below a ‘table’ element are formatted very much as if they were a block element before or after the table, except that (1) they inherit inheritable properties from the table, and (2) they are not considered to be a block box for the purposes of any ‘run-in’ element that may precede the table.”
    “Conforming user agents may interpret the value ‘justify’ as ‘left’ or ‘right’, depending on whether the element’s default writing direction is left-to-right or right-to-left, respectively.”

    • #6
    • Comment
    • Thu 9 Dec 2004
    • 0851
    Chris Hester wrote in to say...

    I read somewhere that captions only take 3 basic formatting styles, which might be border, font and padding. Alas I can’t for the life of me find the relevant page again! If I do, I will post the link here.

    • #7
    • Comment
    • Thu 9 Dec 2004
    • 0917
    Scott Plumlee wrote in to say...

    I just ran across a similar situation. IE has a bug in that form text inputs in a fieldset seem to inherit the parent container elements margin. It’s one of those things that until you happen to set up the exact “wrong” situation, you’ll never see it.
    I wonder if it would be possible to set up a system where you could dynamically select select a series of HTML elements to be included on a page and apply CSS styles to those elements at the same time, then go back and add more elements as children of the first ones, etc. Then you could possibly build a page to test the exact layout you wanted.
    Anyway, this is another one to file away for future hair pulling sessions when things don’t work.

    • #8
    • Comment
    • Thu 9 Dec 2004
    • 0945
    Eric wrote in to say...

    Philippe: you’re correct that caption is defined to be an inline element in the HTML (and XHTML) DTD. However, as ‘Anonymous’ pointed out, any element declared to be display: table-caption is treated as a block element. I interpret that (and note it’s an interpretation) to mean that a table-caption element should generate a block box, and take on the aspects of a block box, the same as if you declared caption {display: block;}.

    Al: !

    Roger: Yes, I noticed that too but wasn’t able to pin it down well enough to report. Once I do, I’ll post about it. (Along with another obscure IE/Win table bug I found.)

    Chris: I’d like to see that. I know there are a very limited number of properties that apply to col elements, but I don’t recall seeing anything about caption elements.

    • #9
    • Comment
    • Thu 9 Dec 2004
    • 1133
    Kevin wrote in to say...

    Eric: you say in your post,


    • #10
    • Comment
    • Thu 9 Dec 2004
    • 2134
    Philippe wrote in to say...

    re [8]: Eric, yes I agree with your interpretation about the display value for caption, and how that works. The problem I see is that IE Win doesn’t understand that value. I’m not sure which algorythms are used by Microsoft (according to the css21 specs they can use different ones for table).

    It then ignores the value ‘justify’. Weird is that it aligns the caption as centered. I thought it’s default value was ‘left’, could be wrong, though. I’ve the habit of always including the text-align property in my stylesheets, to overcome weird inheritance problems.

    • #11
    • Comment
    • Tue 14 Dec 2004
    • 1706
    Seth Thomas Rasmussen wrote in to say...

    The inconsistency with <caption /> is the most absurd simple tag issue since Opera insisted on putting borders on <fieldset /> despite what your stylesheets might have to say on the matter.

    • #12
    • Comment
    • Tue 14 Dec 2004
    • 2254
    Federico wrote in to say...

    Seth (11): That’s not a “feature” but a bug.
    Just add to your CSS:
    fieldset {border:0px solid}

Leave a Comment

Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address required but never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

Remember to encode character entities if you're posting markup examples! Management reserves the right to edit or remove any comment—especially those that are abusive, irrelevant to the topic at hand, or made by anonymous posters—although honestly, most edits are a matter of fixing mangled markup. Thus the note about encoding your entities. If you're satisfied with what you've written, then go ahead...

December 2004
November January