Gatekeeper 1.5 rc3

Published 13 years, 1 month ago

It’s update day!  I just pushed WP-Gatekeeper 1.5rc3 into the public eye.  The major change in this version is that Gatekeeper no longer prevents trackbacks (or pingbacks) from ever reaching your site.  See, before, it was effectively destroying all those without notice or appeal.  Now it just lets them through, whatever their content.

What this means is that Gatekeeper is, as it always was meant to be, a way to prevent comment-form spambots from succeeding.  Trackbots will now get through unless you take other steps, like disabling trackbacks or running another spam filter or something.  I’d actually like to see WordPress split tracks/pings apart from comments, and let you set their “always moderated” flags separately.  Thus you could set things up so all tracks and pings are moderated, but comment-form comments are not.  That would work great for me.  Maybe not so well for others, though.

Unfortunately, rc3 still has that problem where it doesn’t always automatically add a challenge to your comment forms, though you can still get the challenge by manually adding gatekeeper_pose_challenge to the comment forms in your theme.  My grep-fu (or maybe it’s my PHP-fu; or, hell, both) is weak; I can’t figure out why the routine fails.  Anyway, head on over to the Gatekeeper page if you’re interested, and especially if you can figure out why the auto-challenge routine is failing.  Thanks.


  1. You don’t happen to have any examples of pages the automatic-challenge-add is failing on, do you?

    Hard to debug a reg-exp failure without example text for what it is matching against.

  2. The thing works great, but can something be done about the error message that is displayed when someone doesn’t fill in the correct answer? Right now it says that comments are closed, but this is a bit confusing for the average user that overlooked it…

  3. Hey Eric,

    I’m able to get my wp-gatekeeper’s automagic challenge to fail reliably. See this post on my blog for info. If I can be of any help, please don’t hesitate to ask.

    (BTW, I tried to pingback and trackback from my blog to this thread, but neither seemed to work.)

  4. […] theme_switcher, theme, journalized-blue I’m wondering if the known bug in gatekeeper 1.5 depends on which theme you’re running? I’m running jou […]

  5. Unfortunately, rc3 still has that problem where it doesn”t always automatically add a challenge to your comment forms

  6. Ruckus: fortunately, rc5 doesn’t still have that problem.

Leave a Comment

Management reserves the right to edit or remove any comment, especially when abusive or irrelevant to the topic at hand. HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strong> <pre class=""> <kbd>


Comment Preview

If you're satisfied with what you've written, then go ahead...